All Invocation on the Mock Must Have a Corresponding Setup When Setting String Parameter

I have a simple method I am testing. When I run the test I get the error

"All invocation on the mock must have a corresponding setup"

on the last line

dataField.DefaultValue = orderNumber.ToString();

What would cause this?

I am just setting a field.

void IUtilities.SetOrderIdInDocumentMetaData(Document document, int orderNumber)
{
    DataField dataField = null;
    if (document.DataFields.IsPresent(ORDER_ID) == false)
    {
        dataField = document.DataFields.Add(ORDER_ID, AppDefault: false, DocDefault: false);
    }
    else
    {
        dataField = document.DataFields[ORDER_ID];
    }

    dataField.DefaultValue = orderNumber.ToString();
}

This is my unit test code.

[TestMethod]
public void Utilities_SetOrderIdInDocumentMetaData_SetNew()
        {
    string orderNumber = "1";
    int orderId = 1;

    corelDocument
        .Setup(s => s.DataFields.IsPresent(ORDER_ID))
        .Returns(false);

    corelDocument
        .Setup(s => s.DataFields.Add(ORDER_ID, null, false, false, false))
        .Returns(corelDataField.Object);

    corelDataField
        .Setup(s => s.DefaultValue)
        .Returns(orderNumber);

    Utilities.SetOrderIdInDocumentMetaData(corelDocument.Object, orderId);

    Assert.AreEqual(orderNumber, corelDataField.Object.DefaultValue);
}