Did Jeanette Really See Kate?

After a long season of speculation, Episode 9 finally revealed that Kate did, in fact, see Jeanette when she broke into Mr. Harris' on Christmas Eve in '93. When she saw him at the mall, she simply couldn't help herself but take it as a surefire opportunity to break in and get yet another adrenaline rush.

Did Jeanette actually see Kate?

Jeanette and Kate reconciled, and Jeanette even helped Kate uncover her buried memories of what went down at Marin's house. Then, Jeanette publicly forgave Kate on The Marsha Bailey Show. Shockingly, it turned out Mallory was the one who saw Kate in Martin's house (although she didn't realize who she was at the time).

When did Jeannette see Kate in the basement?

But as the sound of Radiohead's “Creep” begins to play, Jeanette smiles and leaves Kate trapped in the basement, revealing that she did know Kate was there in 1994 — and she left her there.