Did Nick Dunne Really Push Amy?

The idea of trusting someone solely on what they say versus tangible evidence is a big theme of the film. When both unreliable sides are shown simultaneously, the shocking truth is revealed. ... The movie even goes as far as showing a scene where Nick pushes Amy to the ground with the intention of hurting her even more.

Did Amy actually love Nick?

However, Amy never accomplished the catharsis of her plan because, she truly loved Nick — although not unconditionally — even after everything that happened between them. As long as he played by the rules, they'd have a perfect relationship.

Why did Amy Dunne frame Nick?

Not only is Amy alive and well, but she orchestrated her entire disappearance just to frame Nick for her murder. ... Amy's plan, ideally, would end with Nick on trial for murder and eligible for the death penalty ... and then with her own suicide, which would seal his fate.