When Are Pumpkins Ready to Pick?

Pumpkins are fully ripe when they have a firm rind, and they have a robust color throughout. Pumpkins should have hard exterior shells that resist denting when you press a fingernail to them. To further ensure their ripeness, you can also tap on the rind, and you should hear a nice hollow thump like a drum.

Can you leave pumpkins on the vine too long?

You should leave pumpkins on the vine as long as you can. They'll only ripen and change color while still growing. Unlike tomatoes and bananas, pumpkins won't improve after picking.

How do you know when a pumpkin is ready to pick?

A pumpkin that's ready for harvest should be fully colored—whatever that hue might be. The rind should also be firm. If your fingernail easily pierces or creates an indentation in the skin, the pumpkin isn't ready to harvest. Pick a pumpkin that's too soft, and it will shrivel within a few days.