Who's Guilty Gudrun or Holger?

Not only is Holger immediately found as the perpetrator, but he is also supposed to pay 30 times the original price of the sailcloth while Gudrun only demanded the original price. At this point, we are presented with a choice to either agree with Sigurd or disagree with his choice.

Do I choose Gudrun or Holger?

You'll first need to navigate a town dispute though between Gudrun and Holger. Listen to their sides of the story and decide who you think is right: it doesn't matter which decision you choose because Sigurd will soon barge in.

Is Holger guilty AC Valhalla?

Instead, Holger is forced to apologize and promise to never do it again, a promise that he will break later on in the story. Ultimately, it's up to the player to decide which outcome they like best, but most seem to agree that Holger is in the wrong.