Why Was Toby on the a Team?

Toby Cavanaugh (Keegan Allen)

Toby isn't a top “A” like Mona. Instead he was a member of the “A Team,” as revealed in season 3, and helped Mona with her devious plans. Toby claims he only joined “A” as a way to keep Spencer safe.

Why was Spencer part of the A team?

4. Spencer Hastings: joined the A team in season three to find information on Toby, who she believed was dead.

What did Toby do as A PLL?

Biography. Toby Cavanaugh is a shy person who was blackmailed by his step-sister Jenna, to have sexual relations with her, saying that she would tell their parents that Toby had been forcing her, in having sex with him, and they would surely have believed her.